So Week 2, we're going to go into more details about
developing a plan. So the first thing we need to do before we go on in negotiation, is we want to develop
very specific objectives. Generally, those got to
be kind of aspirational. What's the best
thing that you want? We're going to later
translate these into what I call reality objectives. But right now, say,
what do we really need? Typically, the objectives
have to really be fair and reasonable and where
contract quantities, delivery times, or you have
to improve supplier quality. Those are the typical type
of objectives that you have. The second thing that's
important is that you're going to probably
make a list of objectives, whether it's quality,
or price, or service, and you got to decide what you must have and what
would you like to have. The reason that's important
is that in the negotiation, there's always give and take and you're going to
obviously want to take the ones that you'd like to have and give those
up if you have to. You want to make sure the
ones that are much have, that you'll hold tight to those. So it's very important. So let's go ahead and
use a question for you. If you're developing objectives, what criteria do you have
in developing objectives? Which ones are important?
What's important about writing a good objective? So I'll give you about 30 seconds here and then we'll
basically come back and go through it. So we use this
thing called SMART. I don't know if you've seen it in other parts of your business. We quite frankly
used it at Colgate. Let me just walk
you through this. So if it's an easy acronym, SMART, if you remember it. Specific for the S, M is for measurable, A is for achievable, R is for realistic,
and T is time. So basically, if you use these, this one, you're
setting objectives, I think you get
better objectives, and you can read through
the definitions here. But basically what it says is you really want
specific, measurable, achievable, realistic,
time based objectives. So if you use that, you'll be able to set better objectives. Let's talk about how you
take this to the next level. So you've made your objectives, what's important or not. I think what you must have the most critical
objectives that you set, is you want to develop what
we call MDOs and LAAs. I'll show you why that's
important in a minute. It's the most desirable outcome. In the best of all circumstances, what would be the most
desirable outcome that you want to achieve either in
price, or quality, or service? We're going to, quite frankly, use price over and over
again in examples, because that's used the
one most frequently, but it can be quality of
service or any other things. The least acceptable term says, I can't go below this amount. What happens if you do? Well, if that's true, if
you really had written an LAA to be exactly
what you want, you're going to have to
walk, and you're going to have to another alternative. We call it the best alternative to a negotiated agreement. Usually, one of the major areas, we'll talk about it
a little bit later, that people don't have a banter. So what do you do if you can't get your least
acceptable alternative? So let's look at how
things are balancing out. This is typically how it works. So you have on the bottom, you're the buyer, you
have an LAA and an MDO, but you may not realize it, but if the supplier has
something like that or might have been trained
about MDOs and LAA, he might have similar ones. What we see here is
this is a trade-off. Hopefully, through probing,
and talking, and listening, you can be able to find that negotiation
window and try to come up with a
negotiated agreement. So let's take a
real life example, because I realize this can
be a little confusing. So let's take the buyer, which is the black here. What he's saying is
that I'd like to pay if I really could, 11 bucks. But if I had to, absolutely I'd pay 11.45. So the most desirable
option for him, is $11, but he'd take 11.45,
if he have to pay for. Conversely, unbeknownst
to the buyer, because he wouldn't know this, the seller also has points. So the seller would love to get 11.50 because that would
really help his top-line, but if he had, he'd take 11.50. What we call this intersection between the buyer and seller, we call it the zone
of likely agreement. You're not going to know
what the seller wants, the seller is not going
to know what you want, but through testing
this and asking questions and getting a feel
where their bottom line is, I think you can get
a pretty good feel. If you can, you're going to come to an agreement that will be mutually acceptable
to both parties. So let's look at a couple of these examples so you
know what happens, and there are many
different scenarios. I'm using price here because that's the
most frequent one, but it could be
quality or delivery of service or something like
that if that was the case. So the first example is where the company and the
supplier are apart. You can see the blue range. They're not anywhere near. So when that occurs,
and you can feel this in a negotiation,
there's no agreement. You're not going to go
anywhere with this. You may have to come back and come back with some
other alternatives or maybe go to your BATNA to be able
to get something done. So this is when no
agreement is really possible because neither
party is even close. The second one, as
you can see here, is a very narrow range. So this is really difficult. It's possible, but you have to really work at it to
find that narrow range. So you've been in these negotiations where you go back and forth for weeks on end, and eventually, you come
to some agreement that's acceptable to parties and it's because it's a
very narrow range. Then you have the next one, which is a wide range, where easy to probably
come to an agreement. What you want to do is be the best negotiator
possible to say, "We've hit the sweet spot
together and because of that, what other things do
we want to include?" Whoever the best negotiator,
which is hopefully you, what are the things they want to include in addition to price? The last one is all
over the board. This is when you have some unrealistic that you've set up, we call the position, just to set the tone
for the meeting. In the case of the
11.15, 11.45, you say, "Look, I'll pay 10 bucks, I want 10 bucks as a buyer." The guy says, "Okay," and you go, "What, there's no way you
could support 10 bucks." So certainly agreement
is possible, but there's a real
problem here because something is wrong
in your analysis. If that's the case, I think you need to figure out what the problem
is pretty quickly. Maybe take a caucus
and go talk about it. So all these things can
happen to you and it's what's your job as a negotiator to figure out when you
can make an agreement, when you can't, if you can't,
you're going to need BATNA. So let's go on to BATNA. So this is really a bottom
line or reservation point. So this has such as, if you have your least
acceptable alternative, which is 11.50, you
have to pay for that, and you can't come
to an agreement. So what happens is, is that you're going to have to probably walk away and
go do something else, and you need to have
what is your plan? Are you going to go to
that second supplier and try to negotiate
a better deal? So it's really after
you've exhausted everything that you
can do, and you can't. Your 11.50 is the absolute
minimum you'll pay, you just have to walk and say, "I'm going have to do
something different here." Sometimes if you learn in the
Harvard Negotiation method, they'll tell you to go to
the balcony and look at, say, what's going on here, and maybe there's other things in order to create value
for both parties, but be it as it may, you have to have a
plan that if you can't hit your least
acceptable alternative. Going a little
further now. You want to take time and analyze
each party strengths, both your strengths and weaknesses and their
strengths and weaknesses. Maybe you negotiate with
them every couple of years, or maybe you're doing it
more than once a year. Whatever it is, you should know their strengths
and weaknesses. You want to know
their personality, the negotiation style, what their education
background is, who they've negotiated before, and you want to assess
what their strengths and weaknesses and you want to
build your plan around. Usually, every
negotiation is unique. Even if you're working
with the same party, it's usually something different. There's different
factors come into play. So you want to be able
to understand that. You want to gather
relative information. Here's the cases: What
happened the last time? Where did we agree?
Where did we disagree? Is the same people going
to be in the room that was a year ago or two years ago, and are there going
to be new people? You want to find that out. Is the boss going
to be in the room? What are the issues to
the suppliers and buyers? You want to find this out. What experience do you have
with the other parties? What are the areas
that you agree on? What are the areas
you disagree on? Any protocols and how you're going to work
together on this? We talked a little
bit about power, trying to look at power in
supply market analysis, what is the power
between the parties? If he's the only game in
town, he's got the power, or do you have the power because you have a large
vine that he needs? So you want to think about the relative information
that you can get before you walk
in the negotiation. The last thing, assuming this as a big critical negotiation, you're going to want
to practice it. Particularly, with
complex, large dollars, five-year contract
is very critical. What I used to do at
Colgate is I would play the supplier and I
used to have a lot of fun with it
because I knew a lot about these people and I have been in these
and watched them. So I paid hard knows supplier and we practice it to see if some of
these things work. Particularly important
in team negotiations, when you have
multiple people that are many non procurement people, and you have to decide who's
going to play what role. For example, you're
going to have absorber, you can have somebody take notes. Is somebody going to
be the finance guy? Who's going to be the
good cop and bad cop? We'll talk about that in tactics. All these things you
want to think about. So let me give you an example, which is a funny one. When I was involved in
Mars plan, Tennessee, we were negotiating for some very specialized
equipment to dry the M&Ms. I talk about this
in the podcast if you want to hear the story again, but the point would be, as there was a lot
of intellectual property that we're adding to the equipment that make it
really work well for us. It was in our
intellectual property, we did not want the
supplier to know about. So one of the ground
rules going into the practice negotiation was
we can't talk about that. I know we were very proud of it, but we can't tell him
because he could take those ideas and sell
them to our competitors. So we're going to buy
basic piece of equipment, put our technology in it, and it's going to work terrific. So we went through that,
the Engineer understood it, we go to the negotiation. Somewhere in the first
five or 10 minutes, the Engineer starts blabbering about this intellectual
property put in. So I fell off my chair. I'd call it caucus, bring
them outside the room, and basically read him right, "I thought we agreed we
wouldn't do it," and he said, "Well, I know and
I'll cancel it." So it wasn't the
end of the world, but the point would be, this is when a practice negotiation
didn't go well. But at least this case when I pulled them
out of the room, I was able to say to him, "You remember we
talked about this, and hopefully you didn't do it as you walked around
the plant with him." So practice negotiations
are very important. Do it for the large
critical items. A couple of takeaways here. Again, we went through
the planning area. Hopefully, you got a feel
for the second time that 70 percent of your time
should be on planning. I hope you got the
idea that you got to write specific objectives, use that smart tool to
write good objectives. You're going to establish
an MDO and LAA, and most importantly, if
you can't hit that LAA, least acceptable option,
you have to have a BANTA. Where are you going to go if
he can't get what you need? Very, very important
for major negotiation. Then lastly, even though I
joked about it a little bit, particularly if it's a
large team, you need to have a Mock Negotiation, which is always critical for
those types of negotiation. So with that, we're
ending week 2.